Windows IT Pro is the authoritative and independent resource for windows nt, windows 2000, windows 2003, windows xp. Features a collection of resources and magazines for windows IT professionals.
  
  
  Advanced Search 


March 23, 2007

WinInfo Short Takes: Week of March 26

RSS
Subscribe to Windows IT Pro | See More News and Analysis Articles Here | Reprints | Or get the Monthly Online Pass—only $5.95 a month!

An often irreverent look at some of the week's other news, including a delayed podcast, some sick Xbox 360s, Vista security compared to other OSes, an MSN Soapbox rollback, YouTube competitors and critics, a limited Apple TV, PS3 in Europe, and much more...

WinInfo Blog

I mentioned last week that Leo and I had recorded another episode of Windows Weekly, but as of today, it's still not available. Leo is away this week, so we're not recording an episode this week, but presumably the latest episode will be posted soon. I think Leo gets bogged down by a draining travel schedule, but I'll drop him a note and see what's up.

Last Friday, the Boston area was whacked by the worst snow storm we've had all year, which isn't saying much, given how little snow we've had. But this kind of later winter storm is typical for the area: The week before had been beautiful, a false spring with 50 degree days. Spring comes here under duress, and you always get that short preview of the new season before the last winter storm kicks in. Well, today, it's 50 degrees again and the last patches of snow are finally starting to melt. I think this is the real thing. (Crosses fingers.)

Microsoft replaced my two dead Xbox 360s this week, which I appreciate. But I'm still concerned about the reliability of Microsoft's console. My understanding is that the company will ship a new Xbox 360 version sometime in the next year that features a lower power consuming CPU, and maybe that will help. But despite repeated denials about reliability issues, I have to think that Microsoft is racing internally to fix these problems.

Short Takes

Microsoft: Vista Safer than OS X, Linux
Microsoft security strategy director Jeff Jones this week published a report comparing the security vulnerability profile for various high-profile operating systems in the 90 days of their existence. Surprisingly, Vista came out in front: Vista had 5 vulnerabilities in its first 90 days, one of them fixed, and one pending with a High severity rating. By comparison, XP had a total of 17 vulnerabilities in its first 90 days, 8 of which were rated High, when it shipped in 2001. The surprises, however, come when you compare the non-Microsoft competition. Mac OS X 10.4, a darling of the press, actually suffered from 20 vulnerabilities in its first 90 days, 8 of which were rated High. Worse, OS X 10.4 still suffered from 17 publicly disclosed but unpatched vulnerabilities at the end of those 90 days. "The data doesn't support [Apple's] marketing," Jones writes. Linux fared even worse: Ubuntu 6.06 suffered from a whopping 71 vulnerabilities in its first 90 days, 27 of those rated High. And there were at least 29 unpatched vulnerabilities in that OS after the 90 day period ended. And so on. You can read the entire report (PDF), and look forward, as I am, to Jones' 6-month and 1-year updates.

MSN Soapbox Shuts Out New Users for Two Months
Microsoft this week shut down new user access to its MSN Soapbox video sharing site for two months so that it can create better controls for preventing users from posting copyrighted content. It's the type of action one wishes Google would take with YouTube, but hey, we're all so touchy-feely about Google that no one would ever suggest such a thing. Microsoft says it has licensed digital fingerprinting technology from Audible Magic to help it filter out copyrighted content, and it will be implemented over the next two months. Unlike Google, Microsoft didn't need to be threatened to take steps to protect others' intellectual property. "We feel this is the right time to make these changes and stand up to do the right thing," MSN Director Adam Sohn said.

News Corp/Fox Team with Microsoft to Fight YouTube
Tired of the seemingly endless copyright infringement happening on video sharing sites such as YouTube, NBC Universal and News Corp. are teaming up to create their own video sharing service, which will provide content from TV shows and movies. But unlike existing services, the new, as-yet-unnamed service will also license their content to a number of other online services. In fact, just about everyone but YouTube owner Google: Time Warner's AOL, Microsoft's MSN, News Corp.'s MySpace and Yahoo have all signed on to access content from the service. In case you're not reading the tea leaves correctly, content owners are getting tired of Google YouTube (and other similar services) raking in millions in ad revenues by hosting others' content on their site and selling ads, and they've decided that it's time for them to get in on the game. And really, good for them. There's nothing more depressing than seeing your content appear on pirate sites.

Apple Ships Apple TV ... It's an iPod for Your Living Room
So you can forget the glowing reviews from Apple sycophants like "The Wall Street Journal's" Walter Mossberg: The Apple TV isn't a revolution, it's just an evolution of a device that Apple's been making for quite some time, the iPod. A simple set-top box that's designed to access PC-based content purchased from iTunes, the Apple TV is simply a version of the iPod designed for your living room, with a nice menu system and networking capabilities. I'll be reviewing the Apple TV on the SuperSite for Windows soon, but you can expect something more realistic and honest that what you might have read about this device so far. In short, it's good but not excellent. It doesn't have DVR capabilities and you can't even change the volume with the limited Apple remote. Eh.

Sony Launches PlayStation 3 in Europe
Sony finally launched its PlayStation 3 video game console in Europe on Friday, giving gamers there a chance to get their hands on the most technically sophisticated console currently available. The PS3 is currently trailing Nintendo's Wii and Microsoft's Xbox 360 from a unit sales perspective, but recent product availability breakthroughs in North America and the European launch are expected to help put Sony over the top. Indeed, Sony says it expects to sell 1 million units in Europe on Friday alone. One issue that Sony still hasn't overcome, however, is the price: The high-end PS3 system costs a whopping 599 euros in Europe, or almost $800, about $200 more than the console costs in the US. My guess is that Sony will cut costs aggressively this year and pull ahead, by a unit sales perspective, by 2008.

Oracle Sues SAP, Claims Corporate Theft
It reads like the plot of a bad movie. Database giant Oracle is suing SAP, alleging that the computer software giant engaged in "corporate theft on a grand scale," by downloading Oracle software and technical support materials. Here, I'll let Oracle describe it: "SAP is engaged in systematic, illegal access to - and taking from - Oracle's computerized customer support systems," the lawsuit reads. "Through this scheme, SAP has stolen thousands of proprietary, copyrighted software products and other confidential materials that Oracle developed to service its own support customers. SAP gained repeated and unauthorized access, in many cases by use of pretextual customer log-in credentials, to Oracle's proprietary, password-protected customer support website." Oracle argues that SAP's "Safe Passage" program, which is designed to help its customers migrate from Oracle to SAP, was derived almost totally from this theft. SAP says it is studying the complaint and has no comment.

Yahoo Ships New Widget Tech for Windows, OS X
If you're into Vista's Sidebar utility or the Dashboard feature in Mac OS X 10.4, you might be surprised to discover that the software they both stole their ideas from, Yahoo Widgets (formerly Konfabulator) was updated this week with a version that is superior to both the Microsoft and Apple implementations. Yahoo Widgets 4 is faster and consumes less RAM than its predecessors, and it adds some interesting new features, like a Sidebar-like dock that can be attached to the side of the screen and a slew of new widgets. Yes, the Yahoo-made widgets connect to Yahoo services, but if you're into Google services or whatever, check out the online gallery, as there's plenty there. From my limited tests so far, Yahoo Widgets 4 is actually quite nice, if you're into this kind of thing.
http://widgets.yahoo.com/

Are Xbox Support Folks Giving Out Private Data?
So after Microsoft shot down rumors this week that hackers had broken into Xbox Live and stolen user account information, a less technical excuse for the thefts was offered by eWeek, which taped repeated telephone conversations with Microsoft's Xbox support staff. According to the publication, lazy support staffers are simply giving out private data, which would allow malicious callers to use the information to steal Xbox Live accounts. If true, this proves my theory about security vulnerabilities, which goes something like this: When it comes to security, humans are always the weakest link.

Mozilla Ships Firefox Security Update
And speaking of security, Mozilla Corporation this week shipped security updates for Firefox 1.5.x and 2.x, fixing a FTP port scanning vulnerability that was being exploited by malicious Web sites. Note, however, that Firefox 1.5.x will only be supported through April 24. By then, all Firefox users are encouraged to upgrade to Firefox 2, which includes some minor functional enhancements over its predecessor. If you are using Firefox, you'll be prompted to install the new update: Please do so.

End of Article



Reader Comments
Scoble (hardly an "Apple syncophant" on the AppleTV:

"I bought an Apple TV tonight.

"I’ve watched Ask a Ninja, Rocketboom, my show, and Ze Frank on it so far.

"Works as advertised. Easy to setup. It rocks.

"I think I’m going to use this almost wholly to look at Internet video shows.

"The integration with iTunes really is great. This is a winner. I take back anything I wrote about it before.

"Oh, and it also supports 1080i HD."

lotsamystuff March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


"Microsoft says it has licensed digital fingerprinting technology from Audible Magic to help it filter out copyrighted content, and it will be implemented over the next two months."

Great. So if I post a clip of somene's wedding video and they're playing "Sweet Caroline" in the background, it'll get flagged as illegal?

This is all so effin' ridiculous.

lotsamystuff March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


The difficulty with saying an Apple product works as advertised is that there are always two messages:
1. This product has X product features.
2. This product will save the world, because it is the most amazing product ever produced.

Scoble is right to say the product works as advertised in the first sense. Paul is also right to say that the product does not work as advertised in the second sense.

tom275 March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


Scoble is an idiot.

"This is all so effin' ridiculous."
Yes, it is. It is ridiculous that you can comment on something before seeing it in action. You don't even have any details of how this is going to work. Moreover, it's going to be a private beta. Ridiculous!

shark47 March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


@lotsa

Scoble always raves about the latest big gadget. He was big into the Xbox 360 media extender (which is much more attactive and useful than the AppleTV, IMO) when it came out, and he is naturally excited to try out a new gadget. Wait a couple weeks to hear a more objective review from him. I won't touch the AppleTV with a ten foot pole - not because I don't like Apple, but because the AppleTV is worthless to me. If I want to play content on my TV, I will get an Xbox 360 and use it. With the supposed price drop this year, the Xbox will cost the same (or less) than the AppleTV, have 5x more features - like DVR, IPTV, HD-DVD playback, Amazing amount of online content you can buy *directly* from the Xbox interface, and finally, play games. The updated Xbox will be quieter and use less power.

I've read different reviews on the AppleTV, and none of them, even from Apple-biased sources, say the AppleTV is a "must-have" item. They say that it is a good device if you want to stream iTunes content to your TV, but if you have a large collection videos in different formats (which would be me), you're out of luck. I certainly don't want to recode all my videos to the inferior Quicktime format! Not to mention I use Windows Home Server as a media server-all my videos and photos are on it. With an Xbox or another media extender, I can immediately stream the content to my TV. I would be more open to purchasing the AppleTV if Apple would *open up* the AppleTV to allow it to stream content from a generic media server, and *not just iTunes*. The iTunes-AppleTV exclusive link turns me off to the whole thing the most. I want something that will play anything stored in *my* format, anywhere *I* specify. Xbox 360 doesn't play all formats, but it does a *much* better job than AppleTV.

NateB2 March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


"Paul is also right to say that the product does not work as advertised in the second sense."

Please specify what product features have been "advertised" that do not work on the Apple TV.

Thank you.

@Sharky: I'm talking about the concept, not Microsoft's particular implementation. The potential downside of "digital fingerprinting" has been discussed ad nauseum here and elsewhere. In the situation I described (and others) it has the potential for substantial unintended consequences. That is why I (and other content producers) are very wary of it. There's no need for you to fly off the handle. I'm simply advocating some use of common sense, and not a heavy-handed use of technology to solve what is largely a nonexistent "problem" that has more to do with corporate greed than anything actually "damaging".

lotsamystuff March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


"@Sharky: I'm talking about the concept, not Microsoft's particular implementation."

1. They're only testing the technology.
2. You have to wait to see how it is implemented before you make snarky comments about it.


BTW, Gizmodo, a semi-Apple-biased source actually recommended the XBox 360 over Apple TV. (http://tinyurl.com/2a82dy)

shark47 March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


For £200 I can buy an Xbox 360 or an AppleTV. From my point of view its a no-brainer for the 360. I fail to see what the AppleTV offers me for the same money?

alanm999 March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


"Scoble is an idiot."

I guess when you can't intelligently discuss the relative merits of the point(s) being made, it's easier to criticize the person or resort to name-calling. That's something I'd expect from *cough*Waethorn*cough*, not you, Sharky. ;-)

Did you think Scoble was an "idiot" when he was a product evangelist for Microsoft, too? Just asking...

lotsamystuff March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


So, the Apple TV is simply a wireless way to show iTunes content on a TV? That's neat and all, but I think the lack of DVR capabilities is crippling for a lot of people. It separates content, which is undesirable, in my opinion, especially for 300 big ones. Add that in (with a 120 GB HDD instead of 40 GB) and I'd go for it.

If you think about it, someone could go out and purchase an Xbox 360 Core for $300 (same price as Apple TV) and they get gaming, DVD playback, and Media Center capabilities (TV w/ DVR, computer content, and radio). To me, that is much more desirable (as long as you have some soundproof casing for the 360 :P).

It seems better to me to have one box for everything than to have a Cable Box, a DVD player, and a "computer box," as most people would probably call it. However, for the everyday consumer, it's great. It's easy to setup and you get HD streaming content on the TV without any complicated setup. The only complaint I think consumers would have is that it doesn't have standard composite output out of the box for compatibility with older TVs. But, judging by the attitude and general tech freak nature of Apple enthusiasts, I think most probably already have an HDTV. I could be wrong though. Only time will tell.

nmt01 March 23, 2007 (Article Rating: )


 See More Comments  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8 

You must log on before posting a comment.

If you don't have a username & password, please register now.




Top Viewed ArticlesView all articles
Command Prompt Tricks

One reader shares his tip for setting up the command prompt to reflect a remote path. ...

PsExec

This freeware utility lets you execute processes on a remote system and redirect output to the local system. ...

How can I stop and start services from the command line?

...


Related Events Check out our list of Free Email Newsletters!

News and Analysis eBooks Business Process Automation - Managing Cost in Your Enterprise

Related News and Analysis Resources Become a VIP member of the Windows IT Pro community!
Get it all with the VIP CD and VIP access. A $500+ value for only $279!

Subscribe to Windows IT Pro!
Solve your toughest technical problems with our experts and access 10,000 + articles online. 30% off

Monthly Online Pass - Only $5.95!
Get instant access to 10,000+ articles from Windows IT Pro Magazine!

TechNet Virtual Labs
Evaluate and test Microsoft's newest products.


Windows IT Pro Home Register FAQ for Windows WinInfo News
Europe Edition About Us Contact Us/Customer Service Media Kit Affiliates / Licensing  
SQL Server Magazine Office & SharePoint Pro Windows Dev Pro IT Job Hound ITTV
IT Library Technology Resource Directory Connected Home Windows Excavator Windows SuperSite 
 
 Windows IT Pro is a Division of Penton Media Inc.
 Copyright © 2008 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Terms and Use | Privacy Statement | Reprints and Licensing