Subscribe to Windows IT Pro
July 06, 2006 12:00 AM

WGA Garners More Attention, All of it Bad

Windows IT Pro
InstantDoc ID #53938
Rating: (50)

Subscribe to this email newsletter at http://www.windowsitpro.com/email/

While Microsoft continues to both defend and roll out its spyware-like Windows Genuine Advantage (WGA) service around the world, the company is facing two WGA-related threats. First, security researchers have identified a software worm that disguises itself as WGA. Second, a new class-action lawsuit was filed against Microsoft late last week, alleging that WGA is spyware and that Microsoft is misleading consumers about the technology.

WGA is a downloadable software service that Microsoft makes available via Windows Update and Automatic Updates. The service is divided into two components: WGA Validation, which checks to ensure that your PC isn't running a pirated version of Windows XP, and WGA Notifications, which is the piece that has raised privacy and security concerns. WGA Notifications was designed to display annoying pop-up alerts to users who are running pirated versions of Windows. But the software was also secretly phoning home to Microsoft servers every time an XP system rebooted. And Microsoft had made WGA a critical security update on Windows Update and Automatic Updates, despite the fact that it was until recently in beta. That means millions of users inadvertently downloaded unfinished Microsoft code to their PCs without understanding what they were doing and how the software behaved.

Since owning up to the software's clandestine behavior, Microsoft changed WGA Notifications so that it doesn't phone home on every system reboot. But the company also took WGA out of beta and began rolling out the service, automatically, to Windows users worldwide. Last week, a class-action lawsuit was filed in the state of Washington, alleging that Microsoft was violating California and Washington consumer-protection laws. Unfortunately for Microsoft, that was only the start of its WGA-related problems.

This week, security researchers at Sophos identified a worm called Cuebot-K that disguises itself as WGA and is spreading via AOL's Instant Messenger network. The worm identifies itself as "wgavn" and "Windows Genuine Advantage Validation Notification," and is installed to run each time the system boots. If the user tries to disable the worm, he or she is warned that doing so could result in system instability. Behind the scenes, Cuebot-K disables the Windows firewall and opens a back door from which hackers could remotely control the PC, steal personal information, or launch Distributed Denial-of-Service (DDOS) attacks.

But wait, there's more. A group of companies and individuals has filed a second class-action lawsuit against Microsoft for delivering spyware to consumers in the guise of WGA and deceiving consumers about its intentions. The suit complains that WGA secretly communicates with Microsoft's servers and "gathers data that can easily identify individual PCs," contrary to Microsoft's assertions.

Microsoft says the suit is without merit. "This distorts the real objectives of the [WGA] program and obscures the real issue, which is the harm to consumers posed by software piracy," a Microsoft spokesperson said. "As with all of our programs, we've gotten constructive customer feedback, the program has evolved, and we've made improvements. Microsoft continues its efforts to foster better communications with its customers."

Related Content:

ARTICLE TOOLS

Comments
  • Orion
    6 years ago
    Jul 07, 2006

    "Speaking of driver issues, Vista will almost never crash because of driver problems. A couple times my Nvidia drivers crashed, but instead of seeing a BSOD, a bubble appeared and said that my graphics driver crashed and was successfully restarted."

    This is because the new driver model for Vista moves a lot of code outside kermal mode and pushes it in to user mode. Meaning fewer BSODs because crashes in user mode don't bring down the system like kernal mode crashes do.

  • Nathan
    6 years ago
    Jul 06, 2006

    I should also mention that the article was updated July 5th, 2006

  • Nathan
    6 years ago
    Jul 06, 2006

    Some cool features (MacHeads, tell me if these are in OS X):

    -Transactional NTFS allows multiple file/folder operations to be treated as a single operation, so that a crash or power failure won't result in half-completed file writes. Transactions can also be extended to multiple machines.

    -"Previous Versions", previously known as Volume Shadow Copy in Windows Server 2003, provides read-only snapshots of files on local or network volumes from an earlier point in time. A new tab in the Properties dialog for any file or folder provides users with straightforward access to these previous versions.

    Also, here is a feature I am fairly certain is in OS X that has been lacking in XP:

    -New support for infrared receivers and Bluetooth 2.0 wireless standards; devices supporting these can transfer files and sync data wirelessly to a Windows Vista PC with no additional software.

  • Nathan
    6 years ago
    Jul 06, 2006

    Have any of you tried installing devices in Vista? Even with the lack of drivers, the ones that do install work almost like a Mac, i.e. simple. As soon as I plug in a device (like a USB mouse), a icon appears in the taskbar for a second, and a bubble pops up saying that a USB mouse was installed. No drivers necessary. It is less intrusive than XP. Just plug it in and almost instantly it works. For my printer (it is networked), I just double-clicked on the printer icon on my network and almost instantly was able to print from it. No wizards involved. I have not tried hooking up a USB printer directly, but I am sure it would work just the same. If a driver is not available on my system, Vista automatically looks online for a driver. It never prompts, no "Add Hardware Wizard" appears, and only if it cannot find a driver do you see a dialog. In this dialog, you have some options: Insert a driver CD so Windows can look on the CD for drivers, manually locate the drivers yourself, ignore this device, or ask again later. It is incredibly painless. No "intro" screen. Only one (1) screen with choices (unless you choose to install drivers yourself.

    Speaking of driver issues, Vista will almost never crash because of driver problems. A couple times my Nvidia drivers crashed, but instead of seeing a BSOD, a bubble appeared and said that my graphics driver crashed and was successfully restarted. What amazed me even more was that I did not experience anything that remotely looked like a crash. Either Vista is lying or it does an incredible job of restarting drivers. I would advise anyone looking to buy a computer to wait until Vista arrives. For reasons, look at this webpage:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Features_new_to_Windows_Vista

  • Sachin
    6 years ago
    Jul 06, 2006

    Probably Microsoft should go back to having two separate divisions for the home OS and business OS, the way they did in the 90s. The business OS can have legacy support etc. The home OS doesn't need that. Also, by having two separate divisions, the home OS doesn't necessarily have to be a ridiculous subset of the professional one.

You must log on before posting a comment.

Are you a new visitor? Register Here

advertisement

advertisement

Windows is a trademark of the Microsoft group of companies. Windows IT Pro is used by Penton Media Inc. under license from owner.