Subscribe to Windows IT Pro
June 28, 2006 12:00 AM

Microsoft Defangs WGA Just a Bit

Windows IT Pro
InstantDoc ID #53892
Rating: (34)

On Tuesday, Microsoft shipped an updated version of its Windows Genuine Advantage (WGA) Notifications tool, the controversial Windows component that security researchers recently labeled as spyware. The new version no longer silently sends information via the Internet to Microsoft each time the PC on which it's installed reboots. Additionally, Microsoft has provided information about removing this egregious software component.

"Our customers have told us that they were disappointed with their WGA Notifications experience, and we have made an effort to improve that with this update," Microsoft wrote in a statement that describes the update.

WGA is designed to help Microsoft prevent software piracy. It's actually two components: WGA Validation, which determines whether the version of Windows on which it's running is legitimate, and WGA Notifications, which displays annoying alerts on pirated Windows copies and "phones home" information to Microsoft on a regular basis.

Recently, Microsoft came under fire for a change in its WGA Notifications component that caused WGA to send system-validation information to Microsoft every time the PC rebooted. Another concern was that Microsoft issued this WGA version to customers as a high-priority update through Automatic Updates and Windows Update, even though it was still beta code. The company was essentially using its customers as guinea pigs without their knowledge, then secretly using the tool to acquire piracy data.

Despite the privacy concerns, Microsoft defended its actions by noting that it has a right to know whether legitimate Windows users are using its software-updating services. The new version of WGA Notifications still displays annoying alerts to pirates. And it still sends data back the first time the test is run (on installation). However, now it won't check every time the system reboots, and it won’t send data back to Microsoft.

If you want to remove WGA Notifications from your system, you should know that it's not as simple as selecting the component in the Control Panel "Add or Remove Programs" applet. Microsoft has made removal instructions available on its Web site, but they are "not tested, supported or recommended." You know, just like WGA itself.

 Microsoft Web site

Related Content:

ARTICLE TOOLS

Comments
  • Nathan
    6 years ago
    Jun 30, 2006

    I should note that I only possess one laptop, and it is running Vista (I have XP MCE 2005 installed on a second partition for application compatibility purposes). My desktop is running Vista only.

    BTW, if you *insist* on crashing XP and not Vista, then I will have to "withdraw." I agree that XP is not secure.

    I would never have guessed that an article on WGA would turn into crashing rival OS's! Talk about off-topic! (I am blaming myself as well as you :)

  • Nathan
    6 years ago
    Jun 30, 2006

    This is getting hilarious. You forgot to ask what version of Windows I am running on my laptop.

    I can send you my Vista build 5464 laptop, but I guarantee that you will not be able to "bring it to its knees". I can let you log on as a standard user. You will soon find it *impossible* to crash Vista so it will no longer boot. Let's count the ways:

    1. Running Regedit? Oops! Requires a password.
    2. Running MSconfig? Oops! requires a password!
    3. Looking at "Device Manager"? Oops! requires a password!
    4.Deleting system files? Oops! Requires a password.
    5. Accessing any other users' files? Oops! Requires a password.
    6. Terminating a process using Task Manager (except for non-critical processes)? Oops! Requires a password.

    There are *plenty* more, but those are the ones off the top of my head.


    My advice: Don't even try!

    My point about the feature in XP was that XP prevents users from deleting system files. I said nothing about spyware/virues being able to get around XP's protection rules, or being able to crash XP (Note "Not perfect" in my sentence).

    I'll bet you 2 $3,000 laptops - wait, make that 5 laptops - if you can crash Vista in one minute. (I'll even set my admin password to 40 chars., like yours)I would like to see you try! It would be funny! If you fail, you only would have to buy me one. :-)

    Maybe we can switch laptops, and when neither you nor I am successful, we can declare a draw :-)

  • Bryan
    6 years ago
    Jun 30, 2006

    Nate:

    Now this will be fun. You send me your laptop and I'll do exactly what you just said: go delete a system file. Maybe a DLL somewhere. And, if you're so proud of Windows being "bulletproof" you should have no qualms about it. The file will magically reappear right!? Just like viruses!!! Hooraaaaayyy!

    (CoolWebSearch anyone? No? No takers? You don't like it when viruses automatically put their files back? Awww, Nate, it seems your "feature" is rather annoying.)

    In return, I'll send you my PowerBook. You find a way to make OS X stop working. Hint: You won't be able to delete any system files - I have a 40 character password for my Root account. You'll need to invest in a large sledgehammer or possibly a blowtorch.

    Sure, you could make photoshop or other programs stop working (and I suppose I could delete solataire off your machine) but OS X will always be there.

    Without installing any hacks or damaging hardware or resorting to viruses, I am confident of two things:

    1) I could bring your Windows machine to its knees in 1 minute or less. (Regedit, anyone?)

    2) You could not make OS X stop booting.


    Bet you a new laptop buddy. ;)

    Advice: Don't take my bait. You simply won't be able to access the files you need to modify to kill OS X without my Root account password. (I'll let you log in to my usual account with no problem and you let me log in to Windows under your usual account too.)

    Oh, wait, that's right... I don't need a password to delete critical things off your machine. It's kind of like taking candy from a baby.

    *snicker* Bulletproof my A S S *snicker*

  • Nathan
    6 years ago
    Jun 30, 2006

    I should also say that the person was *not* a dumb computer user; he is quite intelligent (that's why he bought a Windows PC :-). He needed to run some programs on Windows, and this laptop was a good deal (I personally do not like his choice of laptop - it is a cheap Gateway; the worst part about IMO is that it is *incredibly* difficult to disconnect the computer from the power cord.)

    I find it irritating that you and other posters imply that Mac users are geniuses and Windows users are not. At least one person in the comment section (bonch) uses Macs (duh!) and has some mental issues.

    Any OS's goal should be to make the OS bulletproof; while not perfect, MS solution is great: when a user deletes a system file, if he is successful, the file will "magically" appear back in its place 5 seconds later. Windows prevents users from deleting essential files.

  • Nathan
    6 years ago
    Jun 30, 2006

    I meant that IE 7 was closer to the Safari interface than IE 6. He *only* used Safari on his mac. He would fill "unfamiliar" with IE 6 (plus it is bloated, buggy and insecure)

    That's great that Apple lets people use numbers/letters in their ID key. Microsoft lets you do that too - with their WPA2 setting.

    In fact, Microsoft has a Wireless Network Setup utility that creates a 63 character WPA password (or you can create one) and copies it on to a flash drive in such a way that when it is inserted in other Windows computers, Autoplay kicks in and asks the users if they want to be added to the network. It then adds a wireless network with the correct settings. Apple should adopt something similar.

    Also, why can't Apple let their Airport Express be accessable over a network via IP address? I do not want to install/learn another bloated Apple tool (on Windows) just to change some simple settings.

You must log on before posting a comment.

Are you a new visitor? Register Here

advertisement

advertisement

Windows is a trademark of the Microsoft group of companies. Windows IT Pro is used by Penton Media Inc. under license from owner.