Subscribe to Windows IT Pro

 

Get Newsletters

  • Get the Latest News
  • Product Updates
  • Helpful Tricks
  • Productivity Tips

Subscribe Now!

May 24, 2001 12:00 AM

Access Denied: Understand the Difference Between AD OUs and Groups

Windows IT Pro
InstantDoc ID #20909
Rating: (6)

What's the difference between organizational units (OUs) and groups in Active Directory (AD)? I need to understand the difference between putting a user in the Human Resources OU and putting the user in the Human Resources group.

In Windows 2000 and AD, groups have the same function that they have in Windows NT or other OSs: You put a user in a group to control that user's access to resources. You put a user in an OU to control who has administrative authority over that user. To understand the difference between groups and OUs, consider this: Objects with SIDs (i.e., users, groups, and computers) can act on objects and be granted authority. Groups have a SID, and OUs don't.

For example, in Figure 1, Harry is a member of the Human Resources group and is contained in the Human Resources OU. The Human Resources group has Change access to the HRData folder. Therefore, Harry has Change access to HRData because he's a member of the Human Resources group. The Human Resources OU ACL grants Alice, the departmental administrator, Full Control of user objects, which means that Alice can administer Harry's user account because it's in the Human Resources OU.

An analogy might help you understand OUs. OUs are to AD as folders are to a file server. You no doubt know that each file on a file server has its own ACL but that, by default, files inherit the same permissions their parent folders have. Administrators believe best practice is to avoid maintaining file access on individual file ACLs and to instead use folder-level ACLs to manage access in the same way for all the files in the folder. In AD, like files on a file server, each user and group object has its own ACL that governs not what that user or group can access but who can view or edit that user's or group object's properties.

In AD, because users and groups have ACLs, you can delegate portions of administrative authority to subadministrators. But, just as separately maintaining the ACL of every file is impractical, so is separately controlling administrative authority on each user or group object. Therefore, you can collect into an OU all the users and groups that you want to enable a particular subadministrator to manage, then grant the proper authority over the OU to that subadministrator. Permissions you define in an OU's ACL flow down to all the users and groups in that OU, just as folder ACLs flow down to all the files in a folder. To help you keep OUs and groups straight, remember that a user can be a member of many groups but can reside in only one OU, just as a file can reside in only one folder.

Related Content:

ARTICLE TOOLS

Comments
  • Anonymous User
    8 years ago
    Nov 17, 2004

    10x to the author

You must log on before posting a comment.

Are you a new visitor? Register Here

advertisement

advertisement

White Papers

Get your Windows 7 deployment off to the right start by implementing PC lockdown. A locked-down environment is easier and cheaper to support since users are less likely to make unnecessary changes to the core system configuration - read more here!

Essential Guides

Is your iSCSI "lossy"? The reality is that most off-the-shelf Ethernet hardware deployed for iSCSI can lose packets, resulting in slow performance or application downtime. Learn how to assess your current iSCSI infrastructure and engineer an advanced iSCSI SAN infrastructure.

Web Seminars

What's the best way to keep your network safe from malware? In this web seminar, security expert Greg Shields suggests an alternative method to the traditional blacklisting approach that is common with anti-virus and anti-malware solutions.

eLearning Series

We bring the experts direct to you to share their real-world perspective and expertise. During each event, three sessions stream in real time, so you can learn, ask questions, and get solutions.
Upcoming event: Getting the Most with Exchange 2010 with Paul Robichaux

Subscribe to Windows IT Pro!

Windows is a trademark of the Microsoft group of companies. Windows IT Pro is used by Penton Media Inc. under license from owner.