Free Power Tools Brochure
Get Mark Minasi's
17-page guide today!



      

advertisement

Get Newsletters

  • Get the Latest News
  • Product Updates
  • Helpful Tricks
  • Productivity Tips

Subscribe Now!

July 19, 2010 07:20 AM

Apple: There Is No Problem, so Please Accept Our Free Fix for That Problem and Stop Complaining

Rating: (184)
Windows IT Pro
InstantDoc ID #125618

Hoping that its customers and most ardent followers won't see the logical discord, Apple on Friday strenuously claimed that there was nothing wrong with its beleaguered iPhone 4 smartphone. It then announced that it would provide a free fix for that non-existent problem, apparently hoping that a dose of berating and a cheap gift would simply make the problem go away until the real fix—expected by the end of September—arrives.

After apologizing for having to address the problem in such a public manner, Apple blamed the media for "blowing out of proportion" news coverage of the iPhone 4's many physical and software defects. (Hypocritically, the company has never made such a claim for the commensurately blown-out-of-proportion positive media coverage it normally gets for even the most minor of upgrades.)

To "fix" the iPhone 4 antenna problem—which Apple amazingly claims affects less than 1 percent of users, when in fact it is a hardware defect that afflicts every single iPhone 4 ever made—the company will provide customers who request it with a free "bumper" case that does what a good initial design would have done: cover the antenna and provide protection against the user's hand. These bumper cases typically cost $29 at retail, and Apple will provide refunds for customers who already purchased one.

Of course, this isn't so much a fix as a cover-up. Literally: The bumper covers up the exposed antenna, which allows it to work properly. The iPhone 4 uses a known-faulty external antenna design that other smartphone makers explicitly avoid.

Apple also turned Friday's press conference into a marketing event. It announced that it has sold more than 3 million of the buggy devices since the iPhone 4's launch last month and made bizarre and improbable claims about the iPhone 4's dropped call rates and return rates. The message: There is no problem. And thanks for complaining, but the iPhone 4 is a huge success and maybe the company's best product ever.

Further stretching its credibility, Apple noted that the antenna problems that dog iPhone 4 users are also present in "every smartphone," according to Apple CEO Steve Jobs, and the company provides some video evidence of those claims. Apple's competitors immediately fired back, noting that companies with many years of experience making phone antennas learned how to avoid the iPhone 4 problems long ago.

"Apple's attempt to draw [BlackBerry maker] Research in Motion into Apple's self-made debacle is unacceptable," a RIM statement reads. "RIM has avoided designs like the one Apple used in the iPhone 4 and instead has used innovative designs which reduce the risk for dropped calls, especially in areas of lower coverage ... Apple clearly made certain design decisions and it should take responsibility for these decisions."

"Nokia designs our phones to ensure acceptable performance in all real-life cases, for example when the phone is held in either hand," a Nokia statement reads. Nokia is the world's largest maker of smartphones, by far. It too, does not place antennas on the outside of its devices.

Ultimately, Apple's decision to launch the iPhone 4 with an antenna design that was known internally at the company to be defective for as long as a year is simply the latest in a long line of examples that the company values form over function—often to the detriment of its customers. Steve Jobs refused to change the iPhone 4 antenna, which stretches along the outside of the device, because he was so enamored of the sleek device design it afforded. Apple employees, famously fearful of crossing the dismissive CEO, then saw their concerns about the antenna go unchecked.

Amazingly, Steve Jobs even admitted to this. "The iPhone 4 antenna went through all of this," he said after describing Apple's $100 million dollar antenna testing facility. "We tested it. We knew that if you gripped it in a certain way, the bars were going to go down a little bit, just like every smartphone. We didn't think it'd be a big problem ... Phones aren't perfect."

In the span of 30 seconds on Friday, Jobs claimed this problem affects "every smartphone." But as it turns out, Apple can't officially make such a claim. So on its website, Apple offers a less dramatic claim, noting that "nearly every smartphone can lose signal strength if you hold it in a certain way." The company cites five smartphones as evidence, though it should be noted that two of the five tested devices are Apple's own iPhones.

Much of the media is, of course, lining up like the lemmings they are, lauding the company for acting "prudently" and for "apologizing to customers" and "seizing the bull by the horns." Curiously, few have pointed out that there are 3 million customers out there with bug-ridden devices that will cost them about $2,000 over the life of their two-year AT&T contract. And the antenna problem is only the start of what is now a litany of complaints about the iPhone 4. Will Apple ever admit to these many flaws and do the right thing?

Of course not.

ARTICLE TOOLS

Add a Comment

@1... That is the ONLY article I've seen on the Droid issue, most likely FUD if you ask me... I'm sure Jobs himself posted the video in hopes of drawing attention away from the Iphone 4 debacle ;) Nice troll attempt though.

Young7/21/2010 10:47:57 PM


http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/news/2010/07/screen-defect-found-in-a-number-of-droid-x-devices.ars

Oh noes....issue a recall at once. :)

Lets see if Paul reports on this one.

17/21/2010 11:01:41 AM


By the sounds of it the error can be induced simply by putting your finger over the joint and thus it detunes the antenna. I won't find out as I won't be getting one, I dont like association of the product with its smug like fanatatics. Its like buying a BMW. Great cars but driven by plonkers.

This scrabbling around for points to beat the other person with is getting so tiresome, I mean who cares about the revenue of the company when buying a bar of soap?

Hmm, that Windows phone is coming along nicely...

Gordon7/21/2010 9:23:48 AM


@tamye

The phrase "death-grip," although it normally means a severe grip in common usage, is in this case adopted to refer to a grip that "kills" you phone's reception, not a grip severe enough to cramp one's hands. The grips showcased here are not tight, cramp-inducing grips nor even awkward grips.

http://www.apple.com/antenna/




Vandeley7/21/2010 8:42:57 AM


@@tayme,

I also hope Microsoft does well, and I expect they will. The best thing in the tech world in the last few years is the emergence of Apple as a significant counter to Microsoft; it's good for both companies. The two companies operate in almost orhtogonal markets, with just a little overlap. My opinion is that they each do best when they stick to their strengths. The notable failures on both sides are when they go outside their core competencies.

I'm also pleased to see Android emerge as a real competitor for the iPhone; both products will be better because of it.

The funny thing about Paul's shrill faux outrage over antennagate is that the situation is very much like Vistagate, a few issues that are vastly overblown in the media. In typical hypocritical fashion, he decried the Vista issues and now puffs up the iPhone 4 issues. In both cases, the people actually BUYING the product seem to find the issues very minor. (FWIW, I never commented on Vista since I never used it, and don't have an iPhone 4 either, so all comments are based only on what I've read. Of course, PAUL doesn't have an iPhone 4 either.)

I don't think Apple has handled this as well as they should have. SJ doesn't do humility very well :). However, I think the free case and the silent design change they'll make---probably a clearcoat on the antenna---will be the end of this. The profit numbers don't hurt either; nothing like a few $B in sales to validate a product :).

Jones7/21/2010 8:26:26 AM


@Klimecki - No doubt, they had a stellar quarter...and I have already recognized that. But if you read the first paragraph in your link, it states -

"Apple's stellar financial performance in the June quarter helped ease investor fears, and may silence a chorus of critics who have been hammering the company over its handling of the iPhone 4 "Antennagate" controversy revolving around complaints about signal loss on the new gadget."

Note the use of the word "may". As more and more tech people see Apple's continued foot stomping on this issue, they will "tweet" it and post it on Facebook and the rest of the world will begin to see it. People will be saying things like "If I hold my Nokia the way that Apple says causes the problem, my hand cramps before the signal drops" and similar things. Nobody likes a whiner and everyone wants to slay the giant. Apple is now that giant. Time will tell.

--tayme7/21/2010 8:14:38 AM


@--tayme:

Whatever. No-one except perhaps you and Paul see this as a "PR nightmare"

http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE66J63920100720

Klimecki7/21/2010 8:06:41 AM


Whether you are a simple minded brand loyalist on either side of the issue, Apple is really starting to look petty in this - http://www.apple.com/antenna/ - They have gone on the defensive, and that can never be good. It is still a PR nightmare for them. They are better than this and should just shut up about the issue. Yes, all phones are impacted by attenuation. But, because of the external nature of the iP4's antennae, it is easily de-tuned and looses a high percentage of its signal NOT caused by "blocking" the signal.

--tayme7/21/2010 7:35:44 AM


@O:
You seriously don't get it do you. The ever increasingly anti-Apple rants, incredibly biased 'reporting', name-calling of fellow journalists, perceived frustration and disappointment that beleaguered Microsoft just aren't #1 in tech (some would argue they never were) anymore, the faux outrage and the witnessing of the increasing irrelevance of a convicted monopolist and industry bully makes for a heady mix of online entertainment. Keep it up Paul, you're found an excellent job if making Microsoft look more ridiculous by the day.

Klimecki7/21/2010 2:43:26 AM


It's interesting that the iPod, iPhone & iPad seem to be having a continued positive effect on the Mac. Up 33% on the year ago quarter.

Klimecki7/21/2010 2:26:27 AM


You must log on before posting a comment.

Are you a new visitor? Register Here

Setup rights to helpdesk group to unlock shared files

Does anyone know how to setup a group or permissions for a group (helpdesk) to be able to unlock a shared network file such as a spreadsheet or Access...222-96217

advertisement

GOOGLE LINKS
SPONSORED LINKS
FEATURED LINKS

Podcasts

To successfully implement virtual desktops, IT administrators must carefully match user requirements to specific desktop technologies. Listen to this podcast to learn what you need to keep in mind when formulating your approach to desktop virtualization.

Downloads

PacketTrap IT is a comprehensive and affordable network management and application monitoring solution that solves problems associated with bandwidth, network and application performance, and connectivity. Gain insight into your network - try PacketTrapIT free for 21 days!

Web Seminars

Aside from its employees, data is an organization’s most important resource. Join Windows technical specialist and 11-time MVP John Savill to learn the best practices for managing data using features in Windows Server.
View this web seminar on demand!

eLearning Series

We bring the experts direct to you to share their real-world perspective and expertise. During each event, three sessions stream in real time, so you can learn, ask questions, and get solutions.
Upcoming event: Getting the Most with Exchange 2010 with Paul Robichaux

Subscribe to Windows IT Pro!

Windows is a trademark of the Microsoft group of companies. Windows IT Pro is used by Penton Media Inc. under license from owner.