Subscribe to Windows IT Pro

 

Get Newsletters

  • Get the Latest News
  • Product Updates
  • Helpful Tricks
  • Productivity Tips

Subscribe Now!

March 03, 2005 12:00 AM

Do You Need a Wired Backup Connection?

Windows IT Pro
InstantDoc ID #45579
Rating: (8)

I've been using the Vonage Voice over IP (VoIP) phone service for about 4 months and have been very happy with it. For my small-business needs, it has proved to be quite useful. The flat-rate monthly charge makes budgeting phone expense easy; the online control panel simplifies tracking inbound and outbound calls; the voicemail services are effective and simple to use, and the ability to add additional numbers in different area codes has come in handy. However, over the past week, I had a major setback--and it had nothing to do with the Vonage service itself.
As a precaution, I configured the VoIP service to forward calls to my business cell phone so that I don't miss any calls. I use that cell number as a general backup for the VoIP service, and for communications when I'm not in my physical office. I didn't expect to need more than the cell service as a backup until last week.


My Internet service is provided through Comcast Cable. The service has worked well since I switched to it more than a year ago from my previous satellite-based Internet connection. However, over the past few weeks the service had gotten flakey, with service drops stretching into 12-hour periods and random drops throughout the day.


I contacted Comcast and went through all the rigmarole of level-one tech support; with my explanation to the support tech that I had already tried everything he was telling me to do falling on deaf ears. I did find some of the support tech's suggestions faintly humorous--suggestions that had no relationship at all to the failure of the cable modem to connect, but that's for another column.


As I expected, the problem was with the lines running to my home. In the midst of a pretty good-sized blizzard, a Comcast repair team showed up and confirmed that fact, although they couldn't repair the problem because of the weather. So I was left with an unreliable Internet connection, which meant that my phone service was now in the same state. But because my calls were being forwarded to my cell phone, I didn't miss a call.


But I did lose the ability to send email. With the flakey Internet connection, I couldn't maintain a connection with my ISP's mail server--it kept timing out. To add insult to injury, I couldn't just dial up to my ISP; I didn't have a land line that would let me do so. Without a stable Internet connection, I was cut off from my email, which is a major problem for me.


The end result is that Comcast has got me back up and running, and my email is functioning again, but for a while, I was stuck traveling to the nearest hotspot (which wasn't that near) to send mail. Now I'm seriously considering adding a plain old telephone service (POTS) line to my office as a backup to my Internet connection. It does make me wonder what the future will be for VoIP if users determine they still need a hardwired phone connection. The VoIP decision for me was an easy one; it was the only way I could keep my business phone numbers when I moved my office. But for users just starting out in a new location, opting to go without wired phone service could present a real problem.

Related Content:

ARTICLE TOOLS

Comments
  • Anonymous User
    7 years ago
    Mar 18, 2005

    I've had Vonage for about 2 years and the single outage I've had was because Comcast took 8 days to get to my house to replace a bad filter on their cable. I would tell the service center rep taking the call that we use voip and the field tech cannot call me to verify--but of course the field tech called and didn't get an answer so he didn't bother coming out. At the time I didn't have a cell to forward to, but you can bet I do now. Even with that problem, I'll never go back to pots because the $ savings far outweighed the frustration of that single problem. But I don't use this for business, so I can say that.

  • Anonymous User
    7 years ago
    Mar 17, 2005

    Another option, though not necessarily cheap or available in your area, would be to get a DSL line (Verizon in your area?) in addition to the cable line and pick up a dual-WAN router such as this one:
    http://www.linksys.com/products/product.asp?grid=34&scid=29&prid=639

  • Anonymous User
    7 years ago
    Mar 17, 2005

    During the hurricanes in Orlando, Florida last year, we didn't have any power, cable or cell coverage. The POTS is the only thing that did not go down. Even the cordless phone wouldn't work. I'm glad I saved an old Princess phone.

  • Anonymous User
    7 years ago
    Mar 17, 2005

    I have been using Vonage Since July of last year and have had several Time Warner cable outages. I rely heavily on being able to communicate with others in my group and have made the investment in a GPRS/GSM Blackberry from Cingular as well as an EVDO/CDMA PC card from Verizon. That gives me diversity of medium as well as carrier. With the all you can eat data plans available now the cost for ensuring critical communication is what I consider very reasonable. I am never going back to pots, I agree that dealing with an ILEC is a bad experience.(I do however have an agreement with my neighbor, I will keep Time Warner Cable and he keeps SBC DSL)

  • Anonymous User
    7 years ago
    Mar 17, 2005

    Getting a POTS line isn't going to really fix your problem as it is open to the same mode of failure.

    As for the user saying that the phone companies have a SLA to live up to... good luck on that one! Talking to an ILEC can be one of the most punishing phone experiences a person can have.

    I'd go with some sort of wireless internet as a backup. It all comes down to redundancy costs extra money.
    em

You must log on before posting a comment.

Are you a new visitor? Register Here

advertisement

advertisement

White Papers

Get your Windows 7 deployment off to the right start by implementing PC lockdown. A locked-down environment is easier and cheaper to support since users are less likely to make unnecessary changes to the core system configuration - read more here!

Essential Guides

Is your iSCSI "lossy"? The reality is that most off-the-shelf Ethernet hardware deployed for iSCSI can lose packets, resulting in slow performance or application downtime. Learn how to assess your current iSCSI infrastructure and engineer an advanced iSCSI SAN infrastructure.

Web Seminars

What's the best way to keep your network safe from malware? In this web seminar, security expert Greg Shields suggests an alternative method to the traditional blacklisting approach that is common with anti-virus and anti-malware solutions.

eLearning Series

We bring the experts direct to you to share their real-world perspective and expertise. During each event, three sessions stream in real time, so you can learn, ask questions, and get solutions.
Upcoming event: Getting the Most with Exchange 2010 with Paul Robichaux

Subscribe to Windows IT Pro!

Windows is a trademark of the Microsoft group of companies. Windows IT Pro is used by Penton Media Inc. under license from owner.