November 13, 2006 06:13 PM

Zune Set to Launch Amid Tepid Reviews

Rating: (0)
Windows IT Pro
InstantDoc ID #94232

You might have seen the trying-hard-to-be-hip advertising by now: Microsoft is beginning the marketing death march for its Zune portable digital music player, hoping to convince consumers that there's a viable alternative to Apple's dominant iPod. If the early reviews are to be believed, however, Microsoft first-generation Zune isn't all that exciting. It looks like it's going to be a tough holiday season for the iPod challenger.

Microsoft will begin shipping Zune players to customers tomorrow--Tuesday, November 14, 2006--almost a year after the company's high-profile consumer launch of the Xbox 360. That timing isn't a coincidence: The Zune was developed largely by a team created from the same group that made the Xbox 360, and according to reports, that team has spent all its time since last year working on this new initiative.

Code-named Argo--after the mythological ship that carried Jason and the Argonauts--the Zune is really just a reconfigured Toshiba MP3 player bolstered by a new UI and PC-based client software, both of which Microsoft designed. The company had looked into using its Windows Media Player (WMP) software as the Zune's consumer front end but decided to provide a simpler, Apple-like experience.

This decision, however, came at a cost. In addition to being incompatible with the billions of songs sold through Apple's iTunes Store, the Zune is also incompatible with the songs sold by all of Microsoft's PlaysForSure partners, including MTV URGE, Napster, and Yahoo! Music. It's also incompatible with RealNetworks' Rhapsody service.

What Zune offers in exchange for these incompatibilities is a single unique major feature that even Apple doesn't offer yet: Wi-Fi connectivity. In very limited circumstances, Zune users can share music and photos with one another wirelessly--assuming, of course, that they can even find another Zune user.

If the early reviews are any indication, Apple has little to fear from the first-generation Zune, although Microsoft has pledged to follow it up with more designs in the year ahead. The initial device is heavier and thicker than the iPod, and has worse battery life, even when the Wi-Fi features are turned off. The device is also incompatible with virtually all available iPod accessories and appears to have no compelling reason for existing other than to satisfy the vanity and hubris of certain Microsoft executives.

That said, I'll eventually review the Zune on the SuperSite for Windows, but not until my epic Windows Vista review is complete. I'll also publish hands-on photos and other Zune information in the days ahead.
http://www.winsupersite.com

ARTICLE TOOLS

Add a Comment

My favorite Zune review so far:

http://tinyurl.com/yagwvm

My favorite exchange:

Q: "Why don't they get some good design people over there?"

A: "No Comment"

Lotsa11/16/2006 9:29:16 AM


I'd agree that Zune would not have been born if not for the iPod. More importantly, it is curious but not unlike Microsoft to make a colossal miscalculation due to envy. Had Microsoft spent the dollars and time given to Zune on Vista, maybe we would be getting an operating system worthwhile. as for now, at least in my experience, Vista is chocolate brown with green on the edges....as for Zune......time will tell but the first edition is pretty much a dud according to reviews....

R211/15/2006 7:27:37 PM


I enjoy Paul's site and feel his only misgiving is in too much time is spent defending his opinion and stirring the pot for the boring Windows, Apple, Linux debate. Obviously, he has a lot of knowledge concerning Microsoft, a fair amount where Apple is concerned, but little within the Linux realm. I think when he remains objective he can be informative. Mistakes like headlining an article with "Who is the copycat now" is a bit childish. Arguments such as who did what first are non productive....the bottom line is who really does it best....

R211/15/2006 7:18:42 PM


"Edison fanatics"

But, I'm not sure how many stickers I've gotten from good ol' Tom!!! Heck, he probably invented those, too!!!

--tayme

Mark11/15/2006 5:48:00 PM


@tayme:
"Its all clear now...MS copied Thomas Edison!!!"

Yeah, this is what we need. Edison fanatics to go along with our Apple fanatics.

Or should that be fanboys? Or fanbois? Or fanbpis?

;-)

Chris11/15/2006 5:26:39 PM


I got two stickers when I became a Microsoft Small Business Specialist. Does that mean Microsoft copied Apple for that too?

Oh, whoops. I forgot. Apple doesn't have such a certification.

Joe11/15/2006 4:55:12 PM


I bought a Dillinger Escape Plan CD at a show they played here last spring and got TWO stickers with it.

:-P

Stick11/15/2006 4:37:21 PM


"I think we can all agree that without the success of the iPod, there is no Zune."

And without the success of winamp, there is no ipod/itunes; and without the success of music CDs, no winamp; and without cassettes, no CDs; 45s, no cassettes, and on and on...Its all clear now...MS copied Thomas Edison!!! ;-P

--tayme

Mark11/15/2006 4:26:42 PM


@bmnbmn
"Next people are going to complain that it plays music, so they must have copied Apple."

While I'm not going to say they copied Apple, I think we can all agree that without the success of the iPod, there is no Zune.

Chris11/15/2006 4:01:33 PM


Wait, now people are complaining that there is a sticker in the box? Wow, that IS real important news. And yes, since NO other company has ever put a sticker in a box with their product, I guess MS is copying Apple. Next people are going to complain that it plays music, so they must have copied Apple.

hey11/15/2006 3:05:37 PM


You must log on before posting a comment.

Are you a new visitor? Register Here

advertisement

advertisement

GOOGLE LINKS
SPONSORED LINKS
FEATURED LINKS

eBooks

Playbook for a Virtualized Datacenter | During challenging times, optimizing the IT infrastructure becomes imperative. Many organizations are looking to extend their virtualization efforts to encompass the entire datacenter. Get a step-through of your technology options and more.

White Papers

As the advances in USB devices have made them invaluable to most business users’, they have also exposed organizations to enormous risks. Learn how to easily enforce device/port control and data encryption policies without requiring new infrastructure and additional admin overhead.

WEB SEMINARS

Is Flexible Lockdown Possible? Join Darren Mar-Elia for this free web webinar exploring the various methods you should consider to protect and control your desktops while also understanding the impact on the end user community.
View Seminar On-Demand.

eLearning Series

We bring the experts direct to you to share their real-world perspective, experience, and expertise. During each event, three sessions stream in real time, allowing you to learn, to ask questions, and to get solutions.
Upcoming event: Windows 7 Deployment

Subscribe to Windows IT Pro!

Windows is a trademark of the Microsoft group of companies. Windows IT Pro is used by Penton Media Inc. under license from owner.